The meaning of the lyrics of the song "Contradictions" by the artist "This Providence"

This Providence's song "Contradictions" depicts a tumultuous period in a relationship from the perspective of the lyrical protagonist. He's ridden with guilt for disappointing his lover again, breaking a promise he made. He acknowledges seeing her true feelings when she's not putting up a facade – noticing the contradictions between her words and actions.

The recurring line "I see so much when you're not around" is pivotal. It suggests that the protagonist doesn't see the full picture of their relationship when he's with his lover. Perhaps she's trying to appear strong, masking her true emotions to avoid upsetting him.

He questions her love, as she doesn't try to "find him" or understand his struggles. He desires to help her break free from the addictions holding her back from happiness but is met with tears and a lack of understanding.

The song's latter half reveals the protagonist's remorse. He recognizes his blindness to her struggles, acknowledging that "something was wrong" but he failed to see it. He seeks forgiveness, unsure if he deserves it, acknowledging his role in their situation.

Despite the pain and miscommunication, the protagonist feels his lover's boundless forgiveness and love. He realizes this experience is a valuable lesson, one that will shape him for the better.